Socratic Seminar - "Harry's War"

On Wednesday and Thursday we will be doing Socratic Seminar. We'll probably focus on Metallica's "One" video, but I am also going to pass out a packet on "Harry's War." If we don't discuss it this week, we definitely will during TAKS week.

We are focusing on a blog that recreated the letters of Private Harry Lamin. You can find the blog here: Harry's War.

Embedded here is the text we'll use. There are hundreds of Harry's letters. I focused on the ones concerning his first battles of the war. Life in the trenches was awful. We'll discuss more fully in socratic seminar. But, can you even image?

WWI Socratic Text Harrys War WWI Socratic Text Harrys War David Duez

Metallica's "One"

As a part of our socratic seminar during block day this week, you can also bring a question about the video we watched in class - Metallica's "One." Many of you were probably familiar with the song because of Guitar Hero or Rock Band the video games. How many of you had seen it before? How many of you knew the video was about World War One?

To watch the video again, click here: One Video on Metallica's Site. Just scroll down to the bottom and it is the first one at the bottom.
…And Justice For All
Director: Bill Pope and Michael Salomon
Filmed in December 1988 in Long Beach, CA
Video Premiere Date: January 22, 1989

I can't remember anything
Can't tell if this is true or dream
Deep down inside I feel to scream
This terrible silence stops me

Now that the war is through with me
I'm waking up, I cannot see
That there is not much left of me
Nothing is real but pain now

Hold my breath as I wish for death
Oh please, God, wake me

Back in the womb it's much
too real
In pumps life that I must feel
But can't look forward to reveal
Look to the time when I'll live

Fed through the tube that sticks in me
Just like a wartime novelty
Tied to machines that make me be
Cut this life off from me

Hold my breath as I wish for death
Oh please, God, wake me

Now the world is gone, I'm just one
Oh God, help me
Hold my breath as I wish for death
Oh please, God, help me

Darkness imprisoning me
All that I see
Absolute horror
I cannot live
I cannot die
Trapped in myself
Body my holding cell

Landmine has taken my sight
Taken my speech
Taken my hearing
Taken my arms
Taken my legs
Taken my soul
Left me with life in hell

Words and Music by James Hetfield and Lars Ulrich
Copyright © 1988 Creeping Death Music (ASCAP)
International Copyright Secured All Rights Reserved
Questions you might want to consider for Socratic Seminar for Wednesday:

How did the video make you feel? What do you think it would be like to be that person who survives trench warfare, but just barely? Is it humane to keep the person alive? How did the video bring out the horrors of war?

More info on the song and video:
The song's theme is based on Dalton Trumbo's 1939 novel Johnny Got His Gun. It is based on the story of a soldier whose body was severely damaged after he was hit by a German artillery shell during World War I. His arms, legs, eyes, mouth, nose and ears were gone and he could not see, speak, smell, or hear; but his mind functions perfectly, leaving him a prisoner in his own body.

Metallica is the 7th biggest selling act in American history.

"One" was the first Metallica song for which a music video was created. The music video, directed by Bill Pope and Michael Salomon, debuted on MTV on January 20, 1989. The video is almost entirely in black and white, and features the band performing the song in a warehouse. It features dialogue and several scenes from the 1971 film adaptation of Johnny Got His Gun. Timothy Bottoms can be seen starring as Joe Bonham, the main character in the novel.

Metallica bought the rights to Johnny Got His Gun so they would be able to use it exclusively for the video for "One". Three versions of the "One" music video were made - the first (the longest, album version) contained scenes of both the band and scenes from the movie. The second was simply a shortened version of the first and the third lacked scenes from the movie.

Like many other music videos from the metal band, "One" puts great emphasis on the performances of the band members as musicians, with many shots of Hetfield, Newsted and Hammett's hands picking and fretting. The video features the band members in a typical early Metallica fashion - playing (as if in rehearsal) in some sort of warehouse, in tight formation around Ulrich's drum kit, and dressed in casual street clothes and with long untamed hair.

In the music video, it can be clearly seen that both Hetfield and Hammett are playing ESP guitars. It is also clear that Newsted is playing bass with his fingers at the start of the song, but later switches to a pick.

Two of the three versions of the "One" music video appear on 2 of One, a VHS released on July 1, 1990.

The music video was ranked 38 on Rock on the Net: MTV: 100 Greatest Music Videos and number 1 on Fuse's No. 1 Countdown: Rock and Roll Hall of Fame Special Edition.

The intro:
In the intro there can be heard machine gun fire, explosions and a yelling soldier which all represents a war scene. In the end of the intro there can be heard a fading sound of a helicopter. The sound of the machine gun fire seems to arise again in the instrumental parts - replaced by the drums and guitars.

The inspiration:
Lead singer/song writer James Hetfield has been inspired by Dalton Trumbo's book/movie "Johnny Got His Gun". The idea for the song's opening riff originates from a Venom song called "Buried Alive".

The subject matter:
Hetfield’s reason for writing the lyrics was the thought of being cut off from the outside world just like the main character of Dalton Trumbo's book/movie "Johnny Got His Gun."

"One" was voted as the 7th of the "100 Greatest Guitar Solos" of all time by readers of Guitar World.

Socratic Seminar: World War I Soldier

Next Wed/Thu we'll be having a Socratic Seminar about a World War I blog. It's called: WW1: Experiences of an English Soldier. Click on the link to read more.

This is required reading to have an idea about the topic and to participate in the seminar. We'll be discussing it some in class and wetting your appetite to read through this historical blog. On Wed/Thu you'll be assigned to bring a question to the socratic seminar with you to aide our discussion.

I'm looking forward to seeing how it goes. I think it could be a very instructive class period.

How many of you have actually done a socratic seminar before?

Check this blog for some more postings in the next week about the assignment.

TAKS Tips, Tricks, and Tools

The TAKS Test for Social Studies is coming on Monday, April 27th.

To download some help, click here:
TAKS Tips, Tricks, and Tools

For inspiration about just how excited the TAKS test makes people, check out this cools song: Not On The :)

Video Project Blog

Check out our World History Video Project 09 Blog to see all of the videos from the project. They are great.

Which do you like the best? Leave a comment on that video.

You can search from the videos from an index on the left hand side, or browse through them in the opening post. The opening post is a 'hub' that will show you each of the project videos.

Notes - Chapter 23 - World War I Part I

Chapter 23 - World War I Chapter 23 - World War I David Duez Notes, Chapter 23, World War I

Targets - Chapter 23 - World War I

Chapter23 WWI Targets Chapter23 WWI Targets David Duez World War One, WWI, Targets, World History

Nothing but nets

Here is Mr. Duez in his new "Nothing but nets" Buzzkill t'shirt.

You can get yours by going to One family in Africa tonight is sleeping more soundly because of this t'shirt and donation. Makes me happy.

From their website:
Malaria is a disease caused by the blood parasite Plasmodium, which is transmitted by mosquitoes. Malaria, from the Medieval Italian words mala aria or “bad air,” infects more than 500 million people a year and kills more than a million— one person dies about every 30 seconds.

Malaria is particularly devastating in Africa, where it is a leading killer of children. In addition to being home to the deadliest strain of malaria and the mosquito best equipped to transmit the disease, many areas in Africa lack the proper infrastructure and resources to fight back.
But, it is preventable and treatable. Your donations can help save lives.

Thanks again to Kevin and Iris for their presentation. You can check it out on their website:
AHS SLIP Team Blog
And check out their video here:

Malaria in Africa - Period 3 from fordee on Vimeo.

AVID Field Trip

Some of you may have been wondering, "Where was Mr. Duez on Tuesday?"

Yesterday we took our AVID freshmen class to Rice University. It was a great trip and a BEAUTIFUL day. Perfect weather. It is really an amazing university. The kids were blown away and exhausted when we got back to school.

This is a picture of me and my other AVID freshmen team member. She has a class of freshmen AVID as well. I am so lucky to work with such great people.

I told you it was a beautiful day. But, we are now 4 for 4 in beautiful days for field trips. We have had amazing luck with the weather over the past two years.

Path Training Information

Quick Writes:
Quick Write Quick Write David Duez

Cornell Notes:
Cornell Notes Cornell Notes David Duez

Philosophical Chairs:
Philosophical Chairs Discussion Philosophical Chairs Discussion David Duez

Using Philosophical Chairs:
Using Philosophical Chairs Using Philosophical Chairs David Duez Philosophical Chairs is a technique I learned in AVID. My students enjoy it very much. This is a document to give some tips and tricks on how to do Philosophical Chairs.

Socratic Seminars:
Socratic Seminar Socratic Seminar David Duez

Socratic Directions Socratic Directions David Duez

Document-Based Questions (DBQs):
What You Need to Know About DBQs What You Need to Know About DBQs David Duez How to write a Document based question.

MLK Photos - History Never Dies

One of the things I love about history is that it never ends. It never rests. And just when you think something has been seen from every angle, a new angle emerges:

See the photos on